Jane and holden relationship

Catcher in the Rye-Holdens Relationship with Women - words | Study Guides and Book Summaries

jane and holden relationship

In my opinion based off what i read i believe that Jane and Holden have a more then friends relationship. I believe they have a more then. Holden's relationship with Jane is rather curious. Jane never actually appears in the story, but Holden frequently thinks about her. She seems to be the one girl. In an early scene, Holden hangs around the dorms while his brawny roommate, Stradlater, prepares for a date with Jane Gallagher.

We lived far from any relatives, and our nuclear family unit formed a country all our own, with a specific culture, language, and mores. We liked nerd humor. Sometimes we spoke in fake German accents for no reason.

I may have been the oddest. In a neighborhood dominated by youth soccer and hockey leagues, I was a delicate child who flinched at every revolution of the tether ball, with a vocabulary not so much precocious as inappropriate to the time and place. I was too used to taking my cues from books. When I read Heidifor example, I felt an electric surge of recognition. The perplexed family opens her closet one day to discover a cache of old bread on the floor.

How does Salinger present Holden's relationship with women?

I was absolutely the kind of kid who would hide stale dinner rolls in her room. Childhood, as I knew it, was rife with secrecy and weirdness, with actions that made sense to you but not anybody else. Tove Jansson, who created Moomin, understood that secrecy and strangeness are endemic to childhood.

She was born in Helsinki, the daughter of Swedish-speaking parents, a sculptor father and an illustrator mother. The child Tove roamed around the island by herself, always independent, apparently never lonely. At one point, she took to following the geologist as he worked, unnerving his girlfriend, who turned around and yelled at the child to go home.

jane and holden relationship

As an adult, after art school, she drew political cartoons for a number of places, most notably the satirical, anti-fascist magazine Garm. The Moomintroll family featured first in a series of books, then in a comic strip that ran in newspapers; both were wildly popular. The books became bestsellers in Finland and the U.

The Moomins remain especially popular in Finland, where it is a matter of national identity some Finnair planes have Moomin characters painted on them and in Japan my brother just bought me some Moomin T-shirts at Uniqlo.

jane and holden relationship

In North America, though still popular, the Moomin books never attained quite the same reach. Jansson would be years old this year, and a flood of publications is coming forth to commemorate the anniversary. The Canadian publisher Drawn and Quarterly has been issuing the comic strip versions of Moomin in beautiful new editions, and New York Review Books has been republishing her acute, surprising, adult fiction. Jansson was far from forgotten, but the breadth of her achievement is now clearer than it has ever been before.

Moomin is called a troll, but he looks like a hippopotamus that can walk on its hind legs. He is pale, with no special powers or attributes. Moominpappa is kind but self-involved, forever preoccupied with writing his memoirs or a novel.

Moominmamma is unflappably warm, always rustling up meals and producing snacks and tummy powder from her handbag.

jane and holden relationship

An assortment of creatures fills out the cast, some semi-realistic, others truly strange, like the Hattifatteners, mute, wordless white beings that look a bit like ambulatory mushrooms. Hemulens are self-absorbed depressives, and even the male ones wear dresses.

There is a philosopher muskrat who makes a study of unnecessary things. The universe of Moomin is sometimes magical, with a hobgoblin hat that can change Moomin into an ugly version of himself, but it is also cozy, a paracosm where danger is slight and the next meal of pancakes is never far away.

Yet despite the hominess, the key feature of the Moomin books is a thrumming note of melancholy.

Jane Gallagher

Wistfulness colors many of the scenes, as well as a sense of restlessness that undercuts the security of the family, the valley, the home. Finn Family Moomintroll captures a typical moment this way: Moomin Wood was full of glow-worms, and the sea was disturbed. There was expectation and a certain sadness in the air, and the harvest moon came up huge and yellow. But the sadness in the Moomin universe is more a facet of temperament than event; the books presume that children are already familiar with it, and locate it within themselves.

But the richly varied experiences of childhood, even at their most positive, must be more complicated than happiness. What Moomin feels is often inarticulated; not quite sadness or happiness, but rather childhood emotions and moods that are not categorized or perhaps even nameable by adult language. It is a large world to experience and Moomin, like many children, has neither the language nor the perception to understand it completely.

Sometimes they are overwhelmed. The Moomin books acknowledge this state without disparaging it or explaining it away. Jansson, who lived to be 86, produced many non-Moomin stories, as well as paintings, drawings, and other artwork.

Not coincidentally, the two books have a great deal in common -- both center around a relationship between an older woman and a younger one that is intricate and anti-sentimental.

And both are infused with landscape, an island in summer in one, a small town in winter in the other. The Summer Book is, I think, a perfect novel. This indicates that Holden would have rather done it with an older woman because he values younger girls.

How was Holden effected with the relationships with Jane and by Orlando Estrada on Prezi

He starts flirting with her and says many lies to get her interested. Once again he is very disrespectful and rude and it is also very inappropriate to think like that to a mother of a classmate. On the other hand, he is very generous to the nuns that he meets on the train to Manhattan. It is very surprising when Holden does so many nice things to them such as pick up their basket, respect their beliefs and talk very gently because before he kept complaining about everything.

Holden acts like a real gentleman, which could be because he sees the innocence in them. Holden admires them for trying to help others because later on in the novel the reader finds out that he wants to protect children from danger.

This is the only time that he is uncomfortable talking about sexual things because he respects that they are nuns and does not want to say something impolite. Holden even donates a lot of money when they did not ask for any and after he leaves he even thinks about them a lot and sometimes misses them.

However, Holden does show his immature side when he tries to get together with them but then it gets hard for him to respect girls who do not have the same ideals than him. When Holden meets Sally they spend time together like normal teenagers would do. They go to an ice rink to have some fun but at this point he was already very disrespectful.

It is already obvious that Holden does not like what she is doing and he builds on that until he explodes at the end. He has a conversation with her and finally leaves when she does not want to go away with him. When this happens it is clear that Holden is very serious about leaving and being alone.

Holden says he will call Jane many times but since he never does the reader knows that the character is not developing. Since the beginning of the novel he has been saying this but he never had the will to do it.

In some parts he stands up for Jane and feels the need to protect her like the incident with Stradlater. Another experience he had with a girl his age was with Sunny the prostitute.

How does Salinger present Holden's relationship with women? - GCSE English - Marked by animesost.info

Holden is very gentle to her and respects her very much because he sees how young and innocent she is. He does not go all the way because he feels that she does not know what she has gotten into and he thinks that she is too young to know that prostitution is wrong. Holden also gets much more depressed when she comes in the room, which is also a sign that he feels bad for Sunny.

There are not many young girls in the novel except for Phoebe.

Catcher In The Rye: Holden and Jane

Holden has a very special relationship with his younger sister because they trust and love each other very much. Holden feels that he has to protect children from bad.